Customer Reviews for West York Agway
(U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer)

775 reviews

2650 W Market St   York, PA 17404

(717) 792-1783

Office Hours

  • Mon-Fri: 8 am - 5 pm
  • Sat: 8 am - 3 pm
  • Sun: 11 am - 3 pm
Special Operating Hours
  • 5/26/2025: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • 6/19/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 7/4/2025: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • 9/1/2025: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • 10/13/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 11/11/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 11/27/2025: Closed
  • 11/28/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 12/24/2025: 8:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • 12/25/2025: Closed
  • 12/31/2025: 8:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • 1/1/2026: Closed

Show All Hours

Services at this Location:

Contact Us

(717) 792-1783

2650 W Market St
York, PA 17404

Services at this Location:

Office Hours

  • Mon-Fri: 8 am - 5 pm
  • Sat: 8 am - 3 pm
  • Sun: 11 am - 3 pm
Special Operating Hours
  • 5/26/2025: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • 6/19/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 7/4/2025: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • 9/1/2025: 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  • 10/13/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 11/11/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 11/27/2025: Closed
  • 11/28/2025: 8:00 am - 5:00 pm
  • 12/24/2025: 8:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • 12/25/2025: Closed
  • 12/31/2025: 8:00 am - 12:00 pm
  • 1/1/2026: Closed

Show All Hours

  • 24 hour customer return

Testimonials From Recent Customers

Customer feedback is extremely important to us. We use these reviews to guide our efforts and improve our service. Everything that follows is direct from our customers, without any filtering or editing on our part.

Overall Rating:

Reviews without text are currently hidden. Show them shown. Hide them

Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

PAUL H 
Rating:
5.0

You guys were great. Thank you so much

ROGER A 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

MAURICE H 
Rating:
5.0

Very good people at the Agway store.

BARRY V 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

STEVEN M 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ellen p 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Dorothy S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JARED S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

VERNON M 
Rating:
5.0

friendly, helpful, equipment very clean, asy process for pickup and return

WILLIAM G 
Rating:
5.0

Great place, and great people!

HEATHER G 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JUDY C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JOSEPH P 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

LEONARD L 
Rating:
4.0

Service was quick and friendly

ERIC N 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Charles A 
Rating:
1.0

This whole rental was a mess from the start. Requested a truck less than a quarter mile away. They called and said the truck was not available that they moved my pick up to a location 11 miles away. Well that add $22 to my rental just for mileage so asked if they could prorate me or give any discounts. The gentleman said they could give me a 10 mile reduction to cover half. Not even an 3 hours later another person from uhaul calls saying they need to move my pick up location. Told them about the previous call and apparently there was no notes that i agreed to the new location and no nuts about my discount. So have to renegotiate with this woman. She claims they can't prorate miles but agrees to updrage me from a 15ft truck to a 20ft due to the inconvenience. Agway then calls while i am working asking if there was a mistake with my rental and to call them back about what size vehicle i am getting. So i call 10 minutes before they close and no one answers.... arrive the day of rental and it's a 15ft, not the 20ft that i was promised (have the email showing 20ft) and no prorate on the mileage. Over all, horrible experience. No one that you call has any clue cause no notes are taken.

Brea H 
Rating:
4.0

Making sure that the mileage and gas are checked before handling out any paperwork, with any missing information.

JONATHAN G 
Rating:
3.0

I’m still waiting for a call back to talk about why I loaded up the Uhaul and my help left only to find out it wouldn’t start so we had to wait till someone brought a new battery to put in. The truck was just not up to my standards of past experience. I missed hours of loading and unloading then had to do it myself the next day. I feel I should get some type of refund. I was told by the dispatch that some would contact me. Lucky I’m not in the hospital with my arthritis and back pain. Will never take an old truck again.

VICKIE A 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jonathan F 
Rating:
5.0

Rented a motorcycle trailer here, pick up and drop off was easy and quick.

BRADY R 
Rating:
5.0

West york agway is the greatest. Very friendly and very helpful

JOHN W 
Rating:
5.0

Have pickup trucks at this location !

PAUL H 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Diane T 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

BRIAN R 
Rating:
5.0

Very polite and helpful

Nicola H 
Rating:
4.0

Rear door could have used lubricating very Rusty the reverse light on the driver's side not working other than that the guys at Agway are awesome

VITO P 
Rating:
5.0

The counter service was great, no wait time, and reasonable pricing.

RICKY M 
Rating:
5.0

This place is one of the best places I have ever rented a U-Haul from very friendly and professional

REECE H 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ROBERT Y 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Andrew T 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RICARDO C 
Rating:
5.0

Park trucks far enough apart to allow for quality verification photos

ASH C 
Rating:
5.0

The gentleman who helped me at West York Ag showed great attention to detail even assuring I new the process about my drop off location.

MARK B 
Rating:
5.0

Noah was great and quick with trailer rental. 10/10 recommend agway

SHANE N 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ROBERT W 
Rating:
3.0

Front of cup holder was extremely sticky, did not realize until we already pulled away and went to put it up. Ordered the moving blankets and none were in the truck

Eva T 
Rating:
3.0

Given a dirty uhaul to use and there clean ones on the lot to use.

HELEN Y 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RAY D 
Rating:
5.0

Truck drop off was a much better experience than pick up.

Cory H 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JOSHUA B 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ARTHUR M 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

CHARLES K 
Rating:
3.0

The customer service at this location is superb, and the staff were easy to deal with. The truck was clean and prepared.

JERRY D 
Rating:
5.0

Fantastic experience, will recommend all friends and family to work with Agway in West York PA for their next rental.

MARK V 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

CHRISTINE W 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pamela V 
Rating:
5.0

No improvements needed. Courteous and pleasant staff.

PATRICIA N 
Rating:
5.0

Noah of West York Agway was great! He provided travel & nearby gas station directions, Also, he gave some guidance to ensure we understood the return gas tank requirements. He even helped with the our truck padlock. Overall, we had a very positive experience with West York Agway!

ROERT K 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JEREMIAH S 
Rating:
3.0

The truck had three dings/cracks in the windshield. In addition, there was a large ring etched in the windshield in front of the steering wheel which was distracting during driving. The passenger side mirror was fixed and unable to be adjusted which made side viewing impossible. The U-Haul truck had a very strong cigar odor. I brought it to the attention of Noah at AGWAY. To his credit, he and his employee took the time to spay and wipe down the truck cab which did minimize the odor. In our opinion, this should have been thoroughly checked prior to scheduled arrival. We purposely scheduled pickup at the U-Haul owned facility in York. From our experience, the vehicles at the company owned stores are better maintained and prepped. This was changed by U-Haul without our permission or courtesy of a phone call.

Kenneth S 
Rating:
5.0

Noah and other staff are excellent to work with. Very knowledgeable and motivated to suit customers needs.Ive used their services several times and have been very satisfied with them.

RICHARD R 
Rating:
1.0

Worst customer service

Sushma G 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RANDALL C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ERIC S 
Rating:
5.0

Staff is very helpful, rental was simple, as it should be.

BRUCE J 
Rating:
5.0

Noah at Agway West York was awesome. He recognized that I was doing a one way trailer rental and texted me to offer any assistance ahead of returning the trailer. Made the equipment drop very easy. Highly recommend Agway West York for your U-Haul equipment rental in the York area.

Timothy B 
Rating:
5.0

Staff are A-one. We’ve now worked w three people at this location and they have all been efficient and helpful.

bruce j 
Rating:
4.0

Service was very good young man that waited on us was very friendly and helpful

earline w 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Stephanie M 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Sirena S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Dennis A 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Tony G 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Steve W 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Steve W 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Ralph M 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jeffrey S 
Rating:
3.0

The app needs work. It kept telling me I wasn't in the right location. I had to use my gfs phone for it to work.

Christopher B 
Rating:
2.0

I didn’t receive the appliance dolly that I added to my order . The place I picked up the truck had a fire that morning in the building. I couldn’t go inside to get assistance. I was having trouble with the app. loading my pics of the truck before I left the lot. However I don’t know because at pick up and dropping the truck off I was unable to speak to a human.

Angela O 
Rating:
5.0

I could not check in using the app. I had this same problem last year. The app is no good!

Rachel V 
Rating:
4.0

they are trying to help resolve the overbilling.

David H 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Michelle B 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Nicole R 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

christopher b 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Scott R 
Rating:
5.0

The only thing I didn't realize and wasn't told was about needing to do an online pre-use check. The staff was fantastic and very accommodating especially since I didn't have a reservation.

Yuhri M 
Rating:
5.0

My reservation pick up was changed 3 different times due to being told they didn’t have the truck i needed..Why make a reservation days in advance if u haul is going to not know what stock they have and where

janice w 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

patricia b 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Daniel A 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Brad M 
Rating:
5.0

Very friendly and helpful staff

Timothy E 
Rating:
5.0

Super friendly and helpful gentlemen that assisted me with both pick-up and drop-off.

Tim E 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

margie y 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

sharon w 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Ricardo C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

April S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Nicholas C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Pierre C 
Rating:
5.0

Don't change a thing

BILL L 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Allison B 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jose R 
Rating:
3.0

I was switched to this location after the truck I had originally ordered became unavailable. This ended up being an off-hours pickup - which became an extensive headache, as the location had not set up the truck pickup correctly. It took over an hour for me to get the truck, which set me behind on my move. I'm not sure if this was the location's issue of the U-Haul online service. But, it was very problematic.

Joanna S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

valerie h 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

dena o 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Ricardo C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Nidon V 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

paul h 
Rating:
2.0

They were very nice and made the pick up easy. But upon rturn we were charged a fuel fee because it is showing on the paperwork that we returned the van wth 3/4 of a tank oif gas instead of the 7/8 that it actually was. I submitted photos on the return app as intructed and yet we were still charged an additional amount that we should not have been. I sent an email to the email address listed on the invoice but I have not heard anything back yet.

Linda P 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

misael g 
Rating:
5.0

The staff went out of their way to make sure I had the best experience with U-Haul. A truck that initially had been selected had some issues and they quickly replaced it with another truck. Very please with their service.

James D 
No reviews have been submitted for this location.
  • Moving Trucks

    We have the largest selection of new trucks!

  • Trailers & Towing

    Our cargo and utility trailers start at $14.95!

  • Moving Supplies

    We sell hundreds of products to make moving easier!

  • Trucks for Sale

    We have the largest selection in the industry!

Back
To Top