Customer Reviews for Castle Pawn Shop
(U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer)

649 reviews

534 N Memorial Dr   New Castle, IN 47362

(765) 593-0891

Office Hours

  • Mon-Fri: 10 am - 5 pm
  • Sat: 8 am - 1 pm
  • Sun: Closed
Special Operating Hours
  • 11/26/2026: Closed
  • 12/25/2026: Closed

Services at this Location:

Contact Us

(765) 593-0891

534 N Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN 47362

Services at this Location:

Office Hours

  • Mon-Fri: 10 am - 5 pm
  • Sat: 8 am - 1 pm
  • Sun: Closed
Special Operating Hours
  • 11/26/2026: Closed
  • 12/25/2026: Closed
  • 24 hour customer return

Testimonials From Recent Customers

Customer feedback is extremely important to us. We use these reviews to guide our efforts and improve our service. Everything that follows is direct from our customers, without any filtering or editing on our part.

Overall Rating:

Reviews without text are currently hidden. Show them shown. Hide them

Rating:
1.0

The guy was rude. The dolly was actually of no use to us.

Jeremy A 
Rating:
5.0

Everything was explained to me clearly so that I understood. The truck was clean and ready to go and we had no problems

CHERYL F 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RENEE L 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JAMES L 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

BRIAN H 
Rating:
5.0

My agent was super helpful and courteous. Great service

Brenden D 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RANDALL S 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Clarence K 
Rating:
5.0

Great service! Professional and friendly!

MICHAEL B 
Rating:
2.0

I was told the location did not have the size truck I reserved online so they would give me the bigger truck they had available and charge me the amount for my original reservation. After returning the truck the manager at the location said it must have been a central office issue and he said he had no idea about the price change and that it was not his problem, that he had to do what the computer told him. After looking at my bill in my email I noticed that he added on the extra insurance that I had also declined when renting the truck. The total amount was not that much more. I think around $35 more than I originally reserved for but dealing with the situation was frustrating. He could have offered to contact the person who offered me the discount. I was the only person in the store so it was not like he was too busy. I also called the the office that contacted me to change my reservation and was told the district manager had to approve any refunds and that he would call me to do so, but I have not received any return calls.

Shafik J 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Kimberly J 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

SCOTT S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Anthony D 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Larry G 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Melinda W 
Rating:
5.0

Had a great experience w Uhaul.

LARRY F 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Steven A 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Anthony M 
Rating:
5.0

The A/C was inop. It was very hot in the cab after moving a lot of things.

Zachary J 
Rating:
5.0

Was on time and well maintained. Quick reservation and I also bought boxes.

JASON W 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Richard N 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Travis W 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JEANNE M 
Rating:
5.0

Best U-Haul dealer in the area.

Rex K 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Sarah H 
Rating:
5.0

The owner was amazing, helpful and knowledgeable. Great man to work with

Robert P 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jennifer F 
Rating:
3.0

Moving blankets smelled like dirty attic.

Terry S 
Rating:
4.0

My problem is I scheduled this on line for pick up and delivery at a Muncie location and the online booking changed it to New Castle and the person at the Nee Castle location said that’s common. I know the location I chose, not happy about that U Haul

Daniel B 
Rating:
4.0

Wasn't happy the the location I booked the rental got changed. That cost me extra money for the extra miles. Further more I did not receive a phone call to confirm the change. The new location worked just not happy I couldn't go where I originally booked the truck.

Brad L 
Rating:
5.0

Great Overall Experience.

Brian W 
Rating:
4.0

I was charged more than what I was told online then it was never refunded back to me

WILLIAM L 
Rating:
1.0

Took 25 mins to just pick the key up. Only one person was helping customers. Weren’t friendly either.

BRITTNEY T 
Rating:
5.0

I would say nothing. The experience we had at new castle pawn was great. No customer service issues, seamless transaction.

PERCY B 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

WILLIAM S 
Rating:
5.0

The rental rates of the 5x9 ramp motorcycle trailer jumped from 159 to 572 in 3 weeks. That is price gouging. Your rates will price you out of the business. If I tripled the rate of my rental trucks I would not have any business.

Eric C 
Rating:
5.0

Friendly and efficient service. Prompt update after unit return. Couldn't ask for more.

Barry C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

KEITH D 
Rating:
5.0

Very easy to pick up. Rick had everything anyone could need to attach the trailer to a vehicle. Very nice and professional!

Shari G 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Kalan H 
Rating:
5.0

Really great people to do business with

NICHOLAS M 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

William E 
Rating:
2.0

The back of the truck was dirty had wet oil stains in it I didn’t check it before I left the windows were very dirty and full of smashed bugs and was charged a 25 dollar cleaning fee. The rep was anything but friendly.

Robert M 
Rating:
5.0

Good service/ great value.

AUDIE L 
Rating:
4.0

Great smaller place to rent from.

Keith N 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JANET C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

William L 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Jeff T 
Rating:
5.0

I've used them for car trailer rental a few times and it's always painless and quick to get checked out, they hook it up and check everything, and the equipment is always top notch. Will use them again.

BRANDON C 
Rating:
5.0

Nothing - this was a breeze.

TIMOTHY C 
Rating:
5.0

The CSR was very responsive and helpful.

CHARLES G 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

James C 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

RICHARD N 
Rating:
3.0

Attempted to do self return on the app. As usual, the app wasn't functioning correctly. Was able to scan the location barcode. Instead of the app having me upload any pics or info, it simply said your return is complete, thank you. Dropped the keys in the box and moved on. The next day I received a reminder to return my rental. The rental I had already returned. I looked at my account on the website and it showed that it was still open. So, I wasted more of my time with a call to a representative. She was polite and helpful. She did get the rental returned. I offered to send pics that I took with my phone but she didn't need them. Bottom line is this-if you want to encourage users to use an app to do the check out and in process themselves, then make it function properly. I'm not sure it's worked correctly for me even one time. I have built an app myself, so it's not like I don't know how to use one. As far as the return location, I didn't go inside to interact with any personnel. I have done so before and try my best not to at this location as they are not very friendly and give the vibe that you are interrupting their day, but they are the only game in town so what are you gonna do?

JAMES L 
Rating:
5.0

Don’t let Park Hills U-Haul continue with your company, so they can’t do this to more people!! Thx!!

WANDA F 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

TINA M 
Rating:
5.0

Nothing everything was great!

BILLIE E 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JEFFREY P 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JASON D 
Rating:
5.0

Was a very pleasant experience overall! Very friendly staff and very knowledgeable!

JOEL H 
Rating:
1.0

Not allow a private dealer to put apple air tags on the truck. As in Indiana this is illegal

NICHOLAS M 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

BLAKE O 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JACK T 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ANGELA S 
Rating:
5.0

Great to work with and an easy process.

ROBERT H 
Rating:
5.0

Perfect drop. Thanks!

KEVIN W 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

PAUL W 
Rating:
5.0

Great customer service

JEFFERY S 
Rating:
5.0

The cost per mile is excessive. It was $202 for a round trip of approximately 150 miles. I can rent a car for almost a week with unlimited mileage for not much more than that.

STUART D 
Rating:
5.0

Maybe open a little earlier. 10am Friday was earliest I could pick up

Joe B 
Rating:
5.0

Very helpful

DWIGHT W 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

CHARLES W 
Rating:
4.0

Keep it the same

DENNIS F 
Rating:
5.0

all was great

CLAUDE L 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

AUDIE L 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

BRIAN B 
Rating:
5.0

Very good service

DAVID D 
Rating:
3.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

NICHOLAS M 
Rating:
5.0

We have rented from this location several times and always been very satisfied with their service.

JERRY T 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

dewey h 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

MARY H 
Rating:
2.0

I was over charged on insurance and miles. I didn't drive the estimated mileage yet I was charged for the estimated amount. I didn't want the safe drivenut I was also charged for that. I filled my information and reservation online.

KATHERINE C 
Rating:
3.0

The wiper blades on the truck desperately needs replaced. When it started raining it didn't allow me a clear vision to see. It caused big water streaks all the way across the windshield, so I had to go much slower than predicted for my safety. Other than the wiper blades, the truck ran well and was cleaning adequately before returned back to the shop location.

ALLISON C 
Rating:
5.0

Can't think of anything else they can do, they were very helpful and took care of us!!!

JUDY B 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

REX K 
Rating:
5.0

Good experience

ANTHONY A 
Rating:
5.0

Nothing, the staff was excellent!

NELSON M 
Rating:
5.0

The Box leaked. It rained the night I got it and we loaded it and when we got to out destination I had boxes that were wet. Also my son said there was a wheel out of balance.

ROBERT R 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JEFFREY H 
Rating:
5.0

The gentleman who helped me get my truck set up was very nice very informative.

GEORGE R 
Rating:
5.0

Very please with my service! Thank you.

CANDICE S 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Anthony D 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

KYLE M 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

ESTAVENIA J 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

VICKIE D 
Rating:
4.0

N/a

Paul D 
Rating:
5.0

AWESOME customer service!

DAVID M 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

CYNTHIA B 
Rating:
4.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

Diana R 
Rating:
5.0

Customer did not leave a comment.

JOHN D 
No reviews have been submitted for this location.

Additional Services at this Location

  • Moving Trucks

    We have the largest selection of new trucks!

  • Trailers & Towing

    Our cargo and utility trailers start at $14.95!

  • Moving Supplies

    We sell hundreds of products that make moving easier!

Back
To Top