Should I Rent a Van or Pickup Truck for My Move?

When you’re planning a move, one of the first decisions you’ll make is what kind of vehicle to rent. Vans and pickup trucks each have their own advantages, and the right choice depends on what you’re moving and where you’re going. Luckily, U-Haul offers both, so you can pick the option that fits your needs best. Let’s break down the differences to help you decide.

Start With a Moving Checklist

When deciding if you should rent a van or a pickup truck for your move, start with a list of the size and type of items you need to transport, including furniture, boxes, and appliances. Large items like couches, mattresses, or dining tables can go in a van, which will keep everything protected from the weather and road debris. Alternatively, a pickup truck might be more practical if you have mostly boxes and smaller pieces of furniture.

Distance matters, too. For short, local moves, a pickup truck is convenient and efficient. For longer distances, a van provides added protection and security, especially if the weather isn’t on your side. Finally, consider any delicate items. Things like antiques, instruments, or artwork are better off in a van’s enclosed cargo space.

There are several factors to consider, but it’s worth taking the time to make a list of things to move so you can decide between a pickup truck versus a cargo van. Whichever one you pick, U-Haul is here to support your move with vehicles, packing supplies, and even local moving help to lighten the load. 

Comparing Vans and Pickup Trucks

Both cargo vans and pickup trucks can get you and your belongings from point A to point B, but they each have their pros and cons. Starting with similarities, these vehicles are similar in size, so they can easily navigate tight city streets and smaller parking spaces. They both have comfortable cabs that seat two adults, and their gas mileage is comparable.

Moving to differences, the main distinction between a cargo van and a pickup truck is the shape. Vans have an enclosed cargo area that keeps your furniture and boxes safe from weather, theft, and road debris. On the other hand, if you're moving larger or bulkier items, a pickup truck may be a better option. Its open bed accommodates items that might not fit in a van, so you have the flexibility to transport larger loads without the constraints of an enclosed space. 

Are you making a move that requires a little extra space but not a full-size moving truck? A pickup truck is your best bet. Pickup trucks have towing capabilities, so you can hitch extra cargo to the back.    

Ultimately, your choice between a truck or van will depend on your specific moving needs. U-Haul provides a range of options to ensure you find the right vehicle for your move.

Pros and Cons of Cargo Vans and Pickup Trucks for Moving

Cargo Vans Pros: Enclosed space: Protects furniture and boxes from weather, theft, and road debris. Easy loading: The lower floor height and sliding door makes it simpler to load heavy items without the need for ramps. Max load: Ability to carry up to 4,000 lbs. of cargo, almost twice as much as pickup trucks. Cons: Limited seating: Only features seating for two adults. Size restrictions: Can’t always handle oversized items (like appliances or furniture sets). No towing ability: Less versatile if you also need to haul a trailer.

Pickup Trucks Pros: Open bed flexibility: Can haul bulky or awkwardly shaped items that wouldn’t fit inside a van. Towing power: Strong capacity for cargo, utility, or car trailers. Durability: Built to handle rugged loads and rougher roads. Cons: Weather exposure: Cargo is exposed to rain, wind, and sun unless you add a cover. Loading challenges: Higher bed height makes it tougher to lift heavy furniture in. Less secure: An open bed makes items more vulnerable to theft or shifting in transit.

Cargo Van and Moving Truck Rental Cost

When deciding if you should rent a van or a pickup truck for your move, cost is a key consideration. Rental rates for vans and pickup trucks vary based on how many days you need the vehicle and how many miles you plan to drive, but U-Haul offers competitive pricing to fit any budget.